Supporting Documents by Categories
Related News Articles:
- State Baptist Exec Blames Firing on Interference from SBC Agency – Baptist News Global
- Southern Baptist State Leaders Accuse Mission Organization of Strong-Arming – Christian Examiner
- NAMB’s Kevin Ezell denies confidential ‘Cooperation Agreements’ are ‘gag orders’ – Christian Examiner
- Going Going Gone Sold: Essential Elements of SBC Mission Efforts Response by former Executive Director Looks at Cooperative Agreements
- Petition to NAMB Trustees from Southern Baptists – SBC TODAY
- Can Pepper Hamilton Investigate NAMB? – SBC TODAY
- Former SBC state leader charges mission board with ‘cover-up of wrongdoing’ – Christian Examiner
Topic Short Topic Articles/Summaries
- Troubling Times at NAMB under Dr. Ezell
- Five summary of concerns about Ezell in matters of character, strategy and partnership leadership. Also addresses why these matter to Southern Baptists and Dr. Ezell’s leadership is damaging in the SBC. (1800 words)
- Ezell’s Lies and False Statements: In Response to Denials
Select written and verifiable lies by Dr. Ezell regarding his actions and other false claims. (1100 words)
- Dealing with Decline: The Future of Southern Baptist Cooperation – Is the SBC in Danger of Unraveling at the Seams?
Addresses the pastor and future of the SBC in light of declining resources, along with the roles of parts that make up the SBC ecosystem: associations, state, and national agencies. Role of SBC and Near-Future challenges are addressed, along with 4 proposed affirmations in light of the foundations for SBC mission advance. (2400 words)
McRaney’s Letter of Concern and Responses:
- McRaney’s Letter of Concern re: Ezell NAMB
Initial McRaney 5 page “Letter of Concern” sent to NAMB trustees, various SBC leaders, all State Exec. Directors, and selected others impacted by Dr. Ezell’s actions against McRaney and the MD/DE Convention- NAMB Trustee Response to McRaney Letter Concerns
NAMB Trustee officers response to McRaney’s Letter of Concern 20 hrs. after McRaney electronically sent his Letter of Concern. - NAMB Attorney Letter Feb 29 2016
Letter from NAMB attorneys to McRaney - McRaney’s Response to NAMB Attorney
McRaney response to letter from NAMB’s attorneys letter on Feb. 29, 2016
- NAMB Trustee Response to McRaney Letter Concerns
Ezell’s Secret Financial Threat against MD/DE and against McRaney with Southern Baptist entrusted mission gifts:
- Smoking Guns: Evidence of Ezell Threats Against and Interference with MD/DE State Convention and the Executive Director (McRaney)
In addition to other supportive evidence, there 3 smoking gun evidences of Ezell’s public and secret threats against the MD/DE Convention and their Executive Director, McRaney - Pastor Scott to Warren on Ezell’s Threat Against McRaney and MD/DE Conv.
Email from MD/DE pastor Clint Scott to Bill Warren about Warren’s statements regarding Dr. Ezell’s interference with a threat of withholding financial resources as long as McRaney remained Exec. Dir. - Follow the Money Trail
Tracks the changes in financial commitments from NAMB to the MD/DE Convention based on Ezell’s changing his mind and his threats. Network pastor wrote McRaney was “sold” for NAMB money. - Pastor Scott… “Great Tragedy” in the SBC
Post on SBC Today by MD/DE Pastor Scott from his firsthand conversations and experiences with reflections on both the MD/DE Convention and Dr. Kevin Ezell/NAMB. Scott shares testimony and his reflection on what he calls a “great tragedy”.
- Pastor Wolverton’s Response on SBC Today re: Warren and Ezell
Post on SBC Today by MD/DE Pastor Wolverton from his firsthand, investigated experience and conversations with Network pastors, elected officers, and other pastors.
Evidence for Claims:
- Statements of Fact: Detailed Version
McRaney response to the unexamined denial of the NAMB trustee officers which claimed McRaney’s accusations were factually inaccurate and misleading – 12 page version detailing Lies, False Statements, Threats, Partnership Threats, and NAMB Violations of Strategic Partnership Agreement- Statements of Fact: Summary Version
McRaney response to the unexamined denial of the NAMB trustee officers which claimed McRaney’s accusations were factually inaccurate and misleading – topic summaries in 5 pages outlining Lies, False Statements, Threats, Partnership Threats, and NAMB Violations of Strategic Partnership Agreement
- Statements of Fact: Summary Version
- NAMB vs. Network Timeline Factors 3D
• 3 versions chronicling the actions of Dr. Ezell/NAMB in relating to the MD/DE Convention
• Stages of Pressure by NAMB – 2 page with phase descriptions
• Narrative Sequential Summary of Events – 1.5 page description
• Detailed and Dated Version NAMB Actions Toward MD/DE Convention – 7 pages of dealing with NAMB’s actions with MD/DE - Pastor Scott to Warren on Ezell’s Threat Against McRaney and MD/DE Conv.
Email from MD/DE pastor Clint Scott to Bill Warren about Warren’s statements regarding Dr. Ezell’s interference with a threat of withholding financial resources as long as McRaney remained Exec. Dir. - Follow the Money Trail
Tracks the changes in financial commitments from NAMB to the MD/DE Convention based on Ezell’s changing his mind and his threats. Network pastor wrote McRaney was “sold” for NAMB money. - NAMB Violations Coop Agreement
Detailed description of the violations by NAMB of the Strategic Partnership Agreement - Ezell text threat via Winborn
Evidence of a threat from Ezell – Transcript of Pres. Warren’s reading of the text threat from Dr. Ezell to GMB Board member Thomas Winborn, text received and then read in GMB meeting Feb. 6, 2015
- Ezell claims McRaney refused to meet
Email from Ezell lying, claiming McRaney had repeatedly refused to meet with him and shared with MD/DE leaders.
- McRaney’s 6 Meeting Requests to Ezell via email Reveals Ezell’s lie
Evidence that Warren’s email statement to me and our leadership on Dec. 3 that I had refused to meet with him was a lie. These are time and dated excerpts from some emails.
- McRaney’s 6 Meeting Requests to Ezell via email Reveals Ezell’s lie
Concerns of Ezell/NAMB about McRaney and Responses:
- Ezell’s 3 Concerns re: McRaney Nov 2014
Email from Dr. Ezell to McRaney on Nov. 20, 2014 stating his three concerns with McRaney from his perspective from Alpharetta without firsthand information. - McRaney Response re: Ezell Concerns Nov 2014
McRaney detailed response to Dr. Ezell’s 3 concerns from Nov. 20 email, written since Dr. Ezell had chosen to decline all of McRaney’s requests to meet- Christopherson approved SDOE Rainey
Email from NAMB’s Christopherson demonstrating approval for SDOE Rainey in July before Rainey was approved by MD/DE in August and he began in Sept. (2015)
- Christopherson approved SDOE Rainey
Cancellation of Partnership Agreement:
- Ezell NAMB Letter Canceling Agreement
Dec. 2, 2015 Letter from Dr. Ezell and VP Jeff Christopherson giving notice of cancellation of the historic partnership agreement with the MD/DE Convention- Network Staff with NAMB cuts
Graph describing lost positions of jointly funded staff of MD/DE if NAMB cancelled agreement.
- Network Staff with NAMB cuts
- Network Response Cancel Coop Agreement
McRaney and 3 MD/DE officers letter of response to Dr. Ezell’s and Jeff Christopherson’s letter of cancellation of the partnership agreement with MD/DE Convention - NAMB SPA Strategic Partnership Agreement
Signed and binding Strategic Partnership Agreement between NAMB and MD/DE Convention which started in Aug. 2012.
McRaney and MD/DE Matters:
- Network Accomplishments in 21 Months
McRaney’s late June 2015 reflection on advances in the MD/DE Convention during his 21 month tenure. - Resolution of Support by GMB McRaney Feb 2015
Unanimous vote of MD/DE Board for McRaney and his handling of matters with NAMB/Ezell.
- GMB Letter to McRaney No Accusation & Termination Description
Letter from GMB to McRaney indicating no allegations against him & separation explained (2 pg.) - Warren re-McRaney NOT told Why Terminated
Email by Warren indicating McRaney not told. THEN, McRaney’s email response to Warren with copies to people in Sept. 10, 2015 meeting and select staff members so all would be informed. - 07-07-15 Drew Shofner GMB Letter
Letter by MD/DE Pastor on his reflections after reviewing the actions of the MD/DE General Mission Board to terminate McRaney - Wolverton Reference Letter
Letter from MD/DE Pastor regarding Dr. McRaney after his investigation of the surrounding facts and talking with various leaders in the MD/DE Convention - Pastor Scott… “Great Tragedy” in the SBC
Post on SBC Today by MD/DE Pastor Scott from his firsthand conversations and experiences with reflections on both the MD/DE Convention and Dr. Kevin Ezell/NAMB. Scott shares testimony and his reflection on what he calls a “great tragedy”.
Additional Stats & Fact
- 592 Less plants Ezell
Graph from SBC Annual and stats showing 5 year average for number of plants being 592 less per year during Ezell’s leadership compared to 5 previous years. Some possible difference for possible change in counting methods.
- 70 year low baptisms SBC
Graph from SBC Annual tracking baptisms in the SBC. - Christopherson approved SDOE Rainey
Email from NAMB’s Christopherson demonstrating approval for SDOE Rainey in July before Rainey was approved by MD/DE in August and he began in Sept. (2015)
Biblical and Current Story:
- David and Good Men Gone Astray
Description of how King David went astray and returned to God with parallels to how Dr. Ezell interacted with the MD/DE Convention and McRaney as their Executive Leader
NAMB – MD/DE Matters:
- Cooperative Program Graphs States
Graph showing high support of MD/DE Convention to Coop. Program compared to all states (#4) and also similar size state conventions.
- Christopherson NAMB 3 year budget process
Email from Christopherson – (1) communicating a 3 year process for budgeting instead of previous 1 year budgeting, (2) NAMB and Christopherson do not honor terms of Strategic Partnership Agreement regarding funding ratios.
- NAMB State Budget Funding Categories 2015-17
Budgeting categories which were a base/minimum for the years 2015-2017. However Ezell gave written notice to cancel the agreements and not honor these categories with MD/DE and canceled/replaced with a new agreement with other state conventions. - GMB Statement NO to NAMB 100% Planting
Unanimous vote in Feb. 2015 of MD/DE Board stating they would not take the 100% offer from NAMB.
Other Matters:
- California NAMB Document with Responses 03/01/12
2012 document on how the California Baptist understand the actions of NAMB and their impact on the ministries of Calif. Baptists - Confidential from other State Execs
Quotes and sentiments from other state executive directors, including statements about the secret GAP orders Ezell placed on them with SBC money and threat to withhold the SBC money
- Ezell: NAMB state partnerships remain strong
BP article by Ezell in Nov. 2015 claiming partnerships with State Conventions were strong
- Ezell: NAMB state partnerships remain strong
- Personal Questions Regarding McRaneys
Will and Sandy answer 4 personal questions people have asked them.
- Possible Questions and Concerns
McRaney answers 8 possible questions readers may be asking as or after they review these matters related to Dr. Ezell’s actions on behalf of NAMB Select Questions and Concerns re: NAMB - 2015-16 NAMB Trustees List
- NAMB Trustee List Addresses 2017 List forward
List of names and addresses for SBC trustees assigned to NAMB from SBC Annual - Report Ezell Call Cheek Gilstrap Atlanta
Incident report by DOM (AMS) Larry Cheek regarding the call he received from NAMB President Kevin Ezell to further damage former MI Baptist Exec. Director Bobby Gilstrap
Open Letters by McRaney:
- To Our Family and Friends
- To Our Friends in Maryland and Delaware
- To Our SBC Trustees to NAMB
- To Our Southern Baptist Family
Charts and Facts
Supporting Documents – Alphabetically
- 07-07-15 Drew Shofner GMB Letter
Letter by MD/DE Pastor on his reflections after reviewing the actions of the MD/DE General Mission Board to terminate McRaney - 592 Less plants Ezell
Graph from SBC Annual and stats showing 5 year average for number of plants being 592 less per year during Ezell’s leadership compared to 5 previous years. Some possible difference for possible change in counting methods. - 70 year low baptisms SBC
Graph from SBC Annual tracking baptisms in the SBC.
- 2015-16 NAMB Trustees List
List of names and addresses for SBC trustees assigned to NAMB from SBC Annual - BCMD 10 Year Trend NAMB Coop Program & Annie
Document revealing the 10 year NAMB, MD/DE, and CP Support Trends - California NAMB Document with Responses 03/01/12
2012 document on how the California Baptist understand the actions of NAMB and their impact on the ministries of Calif. Baptists - Cooperative Program Graphs States
Graph showing high support of MD/DE Convention to Coop. Program compared to all states (#4) and also similar size state conventions. - Christopherson NAMB 3 year budget process
Email from Christopherson – (1) communicating a 3 year process for budgeting instead of previous 1 year budgeting, (2) NAMB and Christopherson do not honor terms of Strategic Partnership Agreement regarding funding ratios. - Christopherson approved SDOE Rainey
Email from NAMB’s Christopherson demonstrating approval for SDOE Rainey in July before Rainey was approved by MD/DE in August and he began in Sept. (2015)
- Confidential from other State Execs
Quotes and sentiments from other state executive directors, including statements about the secret GAP orders Ezell placed on them with SBC money and threat to withhold the SBC money - David and Good Men Gone Astray
Description of how King David went astray and returned to God with parallels to how Dr. Ezell interacted with the MD/DE Convention and McRaney as their Executive Leader - Dealing with Decline: The Future of Southern Baptist Cooperation – Is the SBC in Danger of Unraveling at the Seams?
Addresses the pastor and future of the SBC in light of declining resources, along with the roles of parts that make up the SBC ecosystem: associations, state, and national agencies. Role of SBC and Near-Future challenges are addressed, along with 4 proposed affirmations in light of the foundations for SBC mission advance. (2400 words) - Ezell claims McRaney refused to meet
Email from Ezell lying, claiming McRaney had repeatedly refused to meet with him and shared with MD/DE leaders. - Ezell’s 3 Concerns re: McRaney Nov 2014
Email from Dr. Ezell to McRaney on Nov. 20, 2014 stating his three concerns with McRaney from his perspective from Alpharetta without firsthand information. - Ezell’s Lies and False Statements: In Response to Denials
Select written and verifiable lies by Dr. Ezell regarding his actions and other false claims. (1100 words) - Ezell NAMB Letter Canceling Agreement
Dec. 2, 2015 Letter from Dr. Ezell and VP Jeff Christopherson giving notice of cancellation of the historic partnership agreement with the MD/DE Convention - Ezell: NAMB-state partnerships remain strong
BP article by Ezell in Nov. 2015 claiming partnerships with State Conventions were strong
- Ezell text threat via Winborn
Evidence of a threat from Ezell – Transcript of Pres. Warren’s reading of the text threat from Dr. Ezell to GMB Board member Thomas Winborn, text received and then read in GMB meeting Feb. 6, 2015 - Follow the Money Trail
Tracks the changes in financial commitments from NAMB to the MD/DE Convention based on Ezell’s changing his mind and his threats. Network pastor wrote McRaney was “sold” for NAMB money.
- GMB Letter to McRaney No Accusation & Termination Description
Letter from GMB to McRaney indicating no allegations against him & separation explained (2 pg.) - GMB Statement NO to NAMB 100% Planting
Unanimous vote in Feb. 2015 of MD/DE Board stating they would not take the 100% offer from NAMB.
McRaney’s 6 Meeting Requests to Ezell via email Reveals Ezell’s lie
Evidence that Warren’s email statement to me and our leadership on Dec. 3 that I had refused to meet with him was a lie. These are time and dated excerpts from some emails. - McRaney Response re: Ezell Concerns Nov 2014
McRaney detailed response to Dr. Ezell’s 3 concerns from Nov. 20 email, written since Dr. Ezell had chosen to decline all of McRaney’s requests to meet - McRaney’s Response to NAMB Attorney
McRaney response to letter from NAMB’s attorneys letter on Feb. 29, 2016 - McRaney’s Letter of Concern re: Ezell NAMB
McRaney 5 page “Letter of Concern” sent to NAMB trustees, various SBC leaders, all State Exec. Directors, and selected others impacted by Dr. Ezell’s actions against McRaney and the MD/DE Convention - Network Accomplishments in 21 Months
McRaney’s late June 2015 reflection on advances in the MD/DE Convention during his 21 month tenure. - NAMB Attorney Letter Feb 29 2016
Letter from NAMB attorneys to McRaney - NAMB State Budget Funding Categories 2015-17
Budgeting categories which were a base/minimum for the years 2015-2017. However Ezell gave written notice to cancel the agreements and not honor these categories with MD/DE and canceled/replaced with a new agreement with other state conventions.
- NAMB vs. Network Timeline Factors 3D
• 3 versions chronicling the actions of Dr. Ezell/NAMB in relating to the MD/DE Convention
• Stages of Pressure by NAMB – 2 page with phase descriptions
• Narrative Sequential Summary of Events – 1.5 page description
• Detailed and Dated Version NAMB Actions Toward MD/DE Convention – 7 pages of dealing with NAMB’s actions with MD/DE - NAMB SPA Strategic Partnership Agreement
Signed and binding Strategic Partnership Agreement between NAMB and MD/DE Convention which started in Aug. 2012. - NAMB Trustee Response to McRaney Letter Concerns
NAMB Trustee officers response to McRaney’s Letter of Concern 20 hrs. after McRaney electronically sent his Letter of Concern. - NAMB Violations Coop Agreement
Detailed description of the violations by NAMB of the Strategic Partnership Agreement - Network Response Cancel Coop Agreement
McRaney and 3 MD/DE officers letter of response to Dr. Ezell’s and Jeff Christopherson’s letter of cancellation of the partnership agreement with MD/DE Convention - Network Staff with NAMB cuts
Graph describing lost positions of jointly funded staff of MD/DE if NAMB cancelled agreement.
- Personal Questions Regarding McRaneys
Will and Sandy answer 4 personal questions people have asked them.
- Pastor Scott… “Great Tragedy” in the SBC
Post on SBC Today by MD/DE Pastor Scott from his firsthand conversations and experiences with reflections on both the MD/DE Convention and Dr. Kevin Ezell/NAMB. Scott shares testimony and his reflection on what he calls a “great tragedy”. - Pastor Scott to Warren on Ezell’s Threat Against McRaney and MD/DE Conv.
Email from MD/DE pastor Clint Scott to Bill Warren about Warren’s statements regarding Dr. Ezell’s interference with a threat of withholding financial resources as long as McRaney remained Exec. Dir. - Pastor Wolverton’s Response on SBC Today re: Warren and Ezell
Post on SBC Today by MD/DE Pastor Wolverton from his firsthand, investigated experience and conversations with Network pastors, elected officers, and other pastors. - Possible Questions and Concerns
McRaney answers 8 possible questions readers may be asking as or after they review these matters related to Dr. Ezell’s actions on behalf of NAMB Select Questions and Concerns re: NAMB
- Resolution of Support by GMB McRaney Feb 2015
Unanimous vote of MD/DE Board for McRaney and his handling of matters with NAMB/Ezell. - Smoking Guns: Evidence of Ezell’s Threats Against and Interference with MD/DE Convention and the Executive Director (McRaney)
In addition to other supportive evidence, there 3 smoking gun evidences of Ezell’s public and secret threats against the MD/DE Convention and their Executive Director, McRaney - Statements of Fact: Detailed Version
McRaney response to the unexamined denial of the NAMB trustee officers which claimed McRaney’s accusations were factually inaccurate and misleading – 12 page version detailing Lies, False Statements, Threats, Partnership Threats, and NAMB Violations of Strategic Partnership Agreement - Statements of Fact: Summary Version
McRaney response to the unexamined denial of the NAMB trustee officers which claimed McRaney’s accusations were factually inaccurate and misleading – topic summaries in 5 pages outlining Lies, False Statements, Threats, Partnership Threats, and NAMB Violations of Strategic Partnership Agreement - Troubling Times at NAMB under Dr. Ezell
Five summary of concerns about Ezell in matters of character, strategy and partnership leadership. Also addresses why these matter to Southern Baptists and Dr. Ezell’s leadership is damaging in the SBC. (1800 words)
- Warren re-McRaney NOT told Why Terminated
Email by Warren indicating McRaney not told. THEN, McRaney’s email response to Warren with copies to people in Sept. 10, 2015 meeting and select staff members so all would be informed. - Wolverton Reference Letter
Letter from MD/DE Pastor regarding Dr. McRaney after his investigation of the surrounding facts and talking with various leaders in the MD/DE Convention